STOP SEEING INTRUSIVE ADS, & HAVE PREMIUM FEATURES? Stop seeing intrusive ads and have a smoother reading experience, once you sign up on Judicial Poetry. Sign up now!

INCOMPETENT NOTICE OF APPEAL CANNOT BE AMENDED

Reach more audience. Place advert here.

Any notice of appeal that is incompetent cannot be amended because you cannot put something on nothing and expect it to stand.

– K.B. Aka’ahs, JSC. SPDC v Agbara (2019) – SC.731/2017(R)

Was this dictum helpful?

SHARE ON

notice of appeal

JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL IN CRIMINAL APPEAL IS DEFECTIVE

In F.R.N. v. Lamido (2026) 13 NWLR (Pt. 2057) 215 at 248, E—H per Umar JSC: ‘From the foregoing, it is established that in civil matters, the appellants have the liberty to jointly appeal, but there is restriction in criminal matters. Such joint notice of appeal in criminal matters will be incurably defective and incompetent, this is so because it will complicate the appeal and imply that the appellant is inviting the appellate court to determine the rights of the co-accused as well. A court is bound to strike out such notice of appeal even without inviting counsel to address the court on the issue. In so doing, no miscarriage of justice has been occasioned. Any appeal originated without following the Rules of Court is incompetent. See the case of Dokpesi v. F.R.N. (2021) 6 NWLR (Pt. 1772) 195 at 217-218. In conclusion, it is therefore my considered view that the failure of the respondent herein to include the names of his co-accused as respondents on the notice of appeal filed at the lower court was not an irregularity and it did not affect the merit of the appeal as constituted at the court below.’

Was this dictum helpful?

PERSONAL SERVICE OF A NOTICE OF APPEAL IS A REQUIREMENT OF LAW

With profound respect to the erudite senior counsel, this cannot be. As this Court explained, in a most magisterial manner, the term irregularity in respect of procedure, is often construed to denote something that does not fundamentally taint or besmirch a procedure as to render it invalid or a nullity. In other words, an irregularity is deemed to be curable. However, personal service of an originating process, like a Notice of Appeal, is a fundamental requirement of the law.

– C.C. Nweze JSC. Odey v. Alaga (2021) – SC.9/2021

Was this dictum helpful?

WHERE A NOTICE OF APPEAL IS DEFECTIVE

It is not in doubt that a notice of appeal, being an originating process in an appeal process, is a very important document. It is the foundation of an appeal. If it is defective, the appellate Court has no choice than to strike it out on the ground that it is incompetent. I need to emphasis that the question of whether or not a proper notice of appeal has been filed in Court is a question which touches on the jurisdiction of the appellate Court. If no proper Notice has been filed, then there is no appeal for the Court to entertain. See FBN PLC v TSA Industries Ltd (2011) 15 NWLR (pt.1216) 247, Anadi v Okoti (1972) 7 SC page 57, Central Bank of Nigeria v Okojie (2004) 10 NWLR (pt.882) 488, Olanrewaju v BON Ltd (1994) 8 NWLR (pt.364) 622, Abubakar v Waziri (2008) 14 NWLR (pt.1108) 507.

— J.I. Okoro, JSC. Universal Properties v. Pinnacle Comm. Bank, NJA, Opia, Heritage, Fatogun (SC.332/2008, Friday, April 08, 2022)

Was this dictum helpful?

INCOMPETENT NOTICE OF APPEAL WILL BE STRUCK OUT

Where it is established that a Notice of Appeal, the live wire of an appeal, is incompetent, this Court will have no jurisdiction to entertain such appeal. An incompetent Notice of Appeal suffers one natural consequential fate, which is, its liability to be struck out for incompetence. In this appeal, the Notice of Appeal which was filed outside the time required by law deserves no other fate than to be struck out. See Onwuzulike V. The State (2020)10 NWLR (Pt.173) 91 at 102 paras F-G. In the case of Enyibros Food Processing Company (Nig.) Limited V. N.D.l.C. (2021)16 NWLR (Pt. 1800) 559 at 571 paras B – D this Court per Eko, JSC (Rtd) stated the position of an incompetent Notice of Appeal thus: “My Lords because only a competent appeal, validly filed, enures to the appellant to invoke the jurisdiction of this Honourable Court, vested in it by Section 233(1) of the Constitution, to hear and determine appeals from the Court of Appeal, when an appeal appears to be incompetent, it will be properly interrogated to ensure that we do not proceed in an exercise that will eventually be a nullity as well. Madukolu V. Nkemdilim (1962)1 All NIR 587; (1962)2 SCNLR 341, Bronik Motors Limited and Anor V. Wema Bank Limited (1983)1 SCNLR 296, C.B.N. V. Okojie (2015) 5-6 SC (Pt.ii)173; (2015)14 NWLR (Pt.1479)231.”

— J.I. Okoro JSC. Kingsley Okoro V. The State (SC.85/2013, 17 Feb 2023)

Was this dictum helpful?

A NOTICE OF APPEAL IS AN INITIATING PROCESS

A notice of appeal is an initiating process by which a higher Court is invited to review the decision of a lower Court to determine whether on a proper consideration of the facts placed before the Court and the applicable law to the said facts, the lower Court arrived at a correct decision … The filing of a notice of appeal is a necessary prerequisite to the hearing of an appeal. Where leave is required a notice of appeal filed without leave is incurably defective and such notice cannot be amended. See Popoola vs. Adeyemo (1992) 8 NWLR (pt. 257) 1 SC, Abidoye vs Alawode (2001) 13 WRN 71 SC.

— W.S.N. Onnoghen, JSC. SPDC v Agbara (2019) – SC.731/2017(R)

Was this dictum helpful?

APPEAL CANNOT BE DECIDED WHERE NOTICE OF APPEAL IS COMPETENT

My lords, it is of utmost importance and I so bear it in my mind that it is only when a notice of appeal is competent that a determination of it on the merit will be feasible. In other words, where a notice of appeal is incompetent, it is liable to be terminated in limine and it would be of no moment no matter how meritorious it would have been if it were to be considered on the merit. In law, one of the most essential requirement or condition precedent for the competence of an appeal to be determined on the merit by the Court is a valid notice and grounds of appeal, in the absence of which such an appeal would be rendered incompetent and thus incapable of being determined on the merit by this Court for without jurisdiction there can be no competence of any cause or matter or appeal before the Court. It has long been settled in our law that jurisdiction is a fundamental one and thus can be raised at any stage of the proceedings, even on appeal for the first time as in the instant appeal by either of the parties or even by the Court suo motu and once raised it must first be determined one way or the other by the Court before any other issue touching on the merit or otherwise of the respective cases of the parties can be enquired and be determined on the merit by the Court. This is so because in the absence of jurisdiction there can be no competence in the 1st Respondent’s claim to be heard and determined on the merit, since jurisdiction is the life blood of every cause or action and thus where the requisite jurisdiction is found to be lacking, that is indeed the end of the matter. See Madukolu v. Nkemdilim (1962) 2 All NLR 581.

— B.A. Georgewill, JCA. University of Lagos v. Mbaso (2018) – CA/L/775/2016

Was this dictum helpful?

No more related dictum to show.