Judiciary-Poetry-Logo
JPoetry

FOR DOUBLE JEOPARDY TO APPLY, THE CRIMINAL PROCEEDING MUST HAVE BEEN FAIRLY CONDUCTED

Dictum

Section 33 of our 1979 Constitution deals with fair hearing and when it uses the expression “he had been tried”, this must necessitate, imply that at the trial there was a fair hearing. Where, as in this case, there was no such fair hearing, the trial is vitiated or nullified. If the first trial is a nullity, the result will be as though the appellant had not been tried at all and the question of double jeopardy will not then arise. But for a much stronger reason, the same subsection 9 of Section 33 reserves to a Superior Court the right to order that an appellant be tried again in spite of the fact that he had been tried before. I am sure Mr. Rhodes will concede that this Court is a Superior Court.

— Oputa, JSC. G. Josiah v. The State (1985) – SC.59/1984

Was this dictum helpful?

SHARE ON